Community initiative to halt expansion of the local Catalyst industrial waste dump.

Letter 31: Dustfall Study in the Environmental Assessment

bufton@shaw.ca
6407 King Avenue
Powell River
V8A 4X6

POST TO:  Powell River News.com website
COPIES TO:  graham.kissack@catalystpaper.com
Stephanie.Warriner@gov.bc.ca

28 May 2007

The Golder and Associates report, page 29, paragraph 4.2 Dustfall states that monitoring at the Phase 1 landfill was carried out between August 15 – 21, 2006, and again from September 7 -  October 3, 2006.

Data from the Powell River Weather Office shows that two days in the first sample had fog, and 22 of the 27 days in the second sample had either rain, fog, or shallow fog.   Shallow fog is described as a low, under 1 metre fog, which burns off later in the day.  Since the samples were batched, we cannot tell if the dry day samples contain more or most of the contaminants – see enclosed chart.  This moisture in the air obviously has a dampening and therefore stabilizing effect on the ash.  Readings taken after three weeks of a dry July could be very different. 

This information leads me to mistrust the conclusions of the dust hazard associated with the land fill expansion.  Please respond to these concerns.

Thank you;

Joanne Edwards


 

Weather Conditions During Dust Monitoring Period, 2006

 

Date

Condition

August 15

No rain

16

No rain

17

Fog

18

Fog

19

No rain

20

No rain

21

No rain

Date

Condition

September 7

Shallow fog*

8

No rain

9

Rain

10

Rain

11

Rain

12

No rain

13

Rain

14

Rain

15

No rain

16

No rain

17

Rain

18

Rain

19

Fog

20

Rain

21

No rain

22

Shallow fog*

23

Shallow fog*

24

Fog

25

Fog

26

Shallow fog*

27

Shallow fog*

28

Fog

29

Fog

30

Rain

October 1

Shallow fog*

2

Shallow fog*

3

Shallow fog*

* Shallow fog is defined as a low ground fog less than 1 metre deep.